EP253: The Cost of Clarity vs. The Cost of Confusion
Listen Here:
(The notes below are only a brief bullet point summary of what is discussed in the podcast. Be sure to listen to get all of the goodness! If you would like a full transcription of the episode, please send an email to angie@angie-robinson.com.)
One of my most consistent messages, in leadership, in life, and in human interaction, is about the importance of clarity. Clarity in the feedback you give. In talking through change. In critical thinking. Clarity about yourself, your goals, and who you want to be. Getting clear is a foundation.
Most of you would probably say, "Yep, I agree. This is very important." And yet people still feel unclear, unsure, and confused. So maybe we aren't always being as clear as we need to be, and there are lots of reasons why. One thing we may not think about is that everything we do, and everything we don't do, comes at a cost. There is a cost to clarity, and there is a cost to confusion.
I'm writing about this in a leadership and team context, but think about it in any area of your life.
Where Clarity Shows Up
Clarity isn't just about giving good instructions. It shows up in a lot of places:
Direction. Where are we going, why does it matter, and why are we even here?
Expectations. What good looks like, what deadlines look like, what expected behavior looks like, and what happens if those expectations aren't met.
Priorities. What matters most when everything feels urgent?
Roles. Who owns what, who does what, and who makes decisions?
Decisions. What has actually been decided, what's still open, and what isn't open for discussion?
Performance and behaviors. What's going well, what isn't, and how specific can we get to paint a clear picture?
Those are just some of the big hitters. When any one of them is fuzzy, people fill in the gap with their best guess. That's how we're designed. When our brain meets uncertainty, it makes up stories. They could be true, but more than likely they won't be. And every brain is different, so we all guess differently.
You can also turn the mirror on yourself here. Clarity within yourself on all of these things is just as critical. I believe in inside-out leadership: we have to get clear with ourselves first.
The Cost of Clarity
It feels like being clear should be easy, with no downside. That's probably not true. There are real costs to clarity that can keep people from being clear.
Time. This is the default answer for a lot of us. It takes longer to think something through, answer questions, and make sure there's understanding than it does to say what I need to say and move on, or just do it myself.
Skill. Communication is more than saying words. It's understanding how your message lands and what works for the styles and preferences of the people receiving it. Lots of detail matters to one person; too much detail and another person tunes out. Without those elevated communication skills, clarity gets harder.
Discomfort. Being clear about the good stuff is easy. Delivering hard messages is not. By nature, we don't love being uncomfortable, so consciously or subconsciously we may dodge clarity to protect our own comfort.
Commitment. Once I'm clear and specific about expectations or direction, I'm on the hook. I've said it, and now I'll be held accountable. If I keep things a little loosey-goosey, my options stay open.
The risk of being wrong. If I say the thing and it doesn't work, everybody knows I was wrong. We're human. We'll get it wrong sometimes.
Having to say no. Clear priorities may mean someone else's idea doesn't make the list, and someone is going to be disappointed.
Running through most of these is discomfort. These costs are real. I pay them all the time, and I feel every one of them.
The Cost of Confusion
When we aren't clear, we get confusion and uncertainty, and that has a cost too.
A recent Gallup poll found that just under half of US employees strongly agree they know what's expected of them at work, down from 56% in 2020. That means about half the people on most of our teams are guessing. The result:
Rework. Work gets redone because the target moved or was never clear.
Slow decisions. Everything comes back to the leader because no one is sure what they're allowed to decide.
Quiet frustration. People stop asking questions because they don't want to look like they weren't listening or seem like a troublemaker. That quiet frustration can lead to disengagement and people leaving.
Lost trust. When people keep getting it wrong, they start to wonder whether they're the problem, or whether it's the leader or the organization.
Turnover. All of it can add up to people walking out the door.
And there's a ripple effect. What it costs the team, it also costs you as a leader and the organization as a whole.
Clear Is Kind
I always come back to one of my favorite quotes from Brené Brown: "Clear is kind. Unclear is unkind." It's a simple North Star.
When people are clear, they can just get to work. Think of the time and energy spent on hesitation and confusion. With clarity, the energy goes into execution instead of decoding mixed signals. Results improve, and alignment compounds across teams and goals.
I used to think softening a message was the kind thing to do. I'm a recovering people pleaser, and I lead with Earth Green energy, so softening always felt right. But if someone walks away not knowing what I meant, I haven't been kind. I've just been comfortable.
Clear Doesn't Mean Sharing Everything
As a leader, there will always be things you can't share, or can't share yet. What matters is being clear about which is which:
What you know and can share: share it, clearly and early.
What you know but can't share yet: say so. "I can't share that yet, and here's when I expect to know more."
What you truly don't know yet: say that too. "I don't have the answer yet. Here's what I do know, and here's when I'll update you, whether I have more information or not."
Each of those is being clear. Silence is not neutral. When you go quiet, people fill in the gap, and they're rarely filling it in with good news.
There are plenty of frameworks and checklists that help with feedback, priorities, decisions, and change, and I've covered many of them on the podcast. Working with a coach can also help you examine what's getting in the way of your clarity and work through that barrier.
Clarity Through the Insights Color Energies
What clarity looks like differs across personality styles and communication preferences. Using Insights Discovery:
Fiery Red (results-driven, extroverted thinking) is often clear on the what and the how, but may skip the why. Watch-out: the why is foundational for most people.
Sunshine Yellow (enthusiastic, extroverted feeling) is great at the big picture, but may skip the details and deadlines.
Earth Green (values-based, introverted feeling, focused on impact on people) may soften the message so much that it stops being clear. You can be kind and clear.
Cool Blue (data-driven, logical, introverted thinking) is very thorough, but may bury the headline in the detail.
Knowing your lead color energy tells you which part of clarity you're most likely to skip. From there, you can make intentional shifts that elevate your communication and your clarity.
What Do You Think?
W\Are you willing to pay the cost of clarity to minimize confusion?
Links
The Leadership Shift Interest Call
Discover Your Personality Style Quiz [download]
Please leave a review in Apple Podcasts + share with a friend
It will help others find the podcast - the more leaders we can impact - the better our workplaces and lives will be!
Schedule a FREE Discovery Call
Click here to schedule some time - let’s talk about how we can work together through one-on-one coaching, Insights Discovery workshops or other leadership development work!